• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Sundaes with Annabell and Charlotte - Top Ice Cream Shop in Hayward, WI with Vegan & Allergy-Friendly Flavors

Sundaes with Annabell and Charlotte is a charming ice cream shop nestled in downtown Hayward, Wisconsin, known for its rich selection of Chocolate Shoppe ice cream flavors. Their perfect 2 Scoop Sundae stands out, balancing creamy textures with bold taste. The menu thoughtfully includes vegan and no sugar added options, catering to diverse dietary needs—highlighted by innovative oat and water-based bases free from nuts. Paired with local baked goods and classic Wisconsin cheese curds, every visit feels warm and inviting. Friendly staff and a bright atmosphere make it a must-stop for ice cream lovers seeking quality, variety, and care in every scoop.

Sundaes with Annabell and Charlotte at a glance

  • Address 10555 Main St, Hayward, WI 54843, United States
  • Restaurant type Ice cream shop .
  • Popular for Solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Sundaes with Annabell and Charlotte: Reviews & Ratings

Michaela Nofftz
4

Little shop downtown serving Wisconsin’s own Chocolate Shoppe ice cream. So many flavors! Offers some vegan and no sugar added options as well as local baked goods.

J & R H
5

Clean, bright and friendly. Delicious ice cream!!! Will be back for sure.

Joe Gracyalny
5

Visited here after Cranfest in Stone Lake. Great customer service and the ice cream was phenomenal! Worth a stop after dinner downtown

Grant Hagen
4

Good ice cream options - especially the blackberry lemon bar! Stopped in on a rainy Saturday at the cabin this past weekend and only one person was serving an endless line of customers. We came in at an opportune time and were served quickly, but others were less fortunate.

Ivonne Benitez
5

I wish this were a nationwide chain, there are soooo many yummy flavors!!! We were blown away by the amount of vegan options. It is amazing to see water-based and oatmilk based options with no nuts. The employees were also very kind and attentive. Thank you Sundaes with Annabell and Charlotte, thank you for providing a safe place for my son with food allergies!

D L H
5

Good icecream friendly staff even with a few Karen's complaints about that leaving low reviews. Popcorn flavors make the whole place smell great.

Ivy Berg
5

Eight dairy-free ice cream flavors!!!!! We are stopping here every time we pass through Hayward!!! So good!

Joe
5

Stopped in Hayward on the way through to Bayfield and decided to look for ice cream. Was not aware the muskie festival was going on! Watched the parade for a bit, then snuck in here before it was over, so it wasn't too busy yet. Great selection of ice cream. Yippy Skippy was a favorite, and Superman and Cotton Candy. Did the 2 scoop bowl for everyone even though it was kind of expensive at like $8 per bowl. However, when I saw the kids walking out with their bowls (I was waiting on the sidewalk with the dogs), I was shocked that my wife would let them get that much ice cream. Then she informed me it was the 2 scoop bowl??? Maybe it was more 'a bowl filled with 2 kinds of ice cream'? The serving size was generous, and it's the first time I have seen our kids complain about having to finish their ice cream. So, while expensive, it was worthwhile, servings are good size and dozens of flavors to choose from, but my recommendation is to stick with the 1 scoop unless you just cannot decide between 2 flavors. Also, they do have a nutrition sign out front if you need it. A quick overview of it- if you need to know that information, just keep walking.

Location

  • Sundaes with Annabell and Charlotte
    Sundaes with Annabell and Charlotte
    10555 Main St, Hayward, WI 54843, United States

Nestled in the heart of Hayward, Wisconsin, Sundaes with Annabell and Charlotte is a charming ice cream shop that celebrates local flavor and inclusive indulgence. Known for serving Wisconsin’s own renowned Chocolate Shoppe ice cream, this cozy spot offers a refreshing variety of flavors that cater to every palate, including thoughtfully crafted vegan and no sugar added options. The fusion of traditional and innovative choices makes it a standout destination for ice cream lovers.

The Perfect Sundae is a must-try here — a harmonious blend of rich, creamy scoops layered with fresh toppings that leave a lasting impression. Their 2 Scoop Sundae option is both generous and satisfying, allowing visitors to mix and match from the array of enticing flavors. An unexpected but delightful local twist is their serving of classic Wisconsin Cheese Curds, which adds a savory balance to the sweet treats and showcases the region’s dairy heritage.

What truly sets this shop apart is its commitment to inclusivity and health-conscious choices. With a wide selection of water-based and oat milk-based vegan ice creams free of nuts, Sundaes with Annabell and Charlotte welcomes guests with food sensitivities and allergies, creating a safe and enjoyable experience for all. Customers often praise the friendly and attentive staff who enhance the warm, bright, and clean atmosphere, making each visit feel personal and memorable.

Visiting after a local event or simply on a cozy weekend, the shop consistently delivers phenomenal flavors and service. Whether you’re craving the tangy sweetness of the blackberry lemon bar or exploring their ever-changing lineup of flavors, this ice cream haven promises a delightful treat. For anyone seeking an authentic taste of Wisconsin with an inclusive twist, Sundaes with Annabell and Charlotte is a destination well worth the stop.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair accessible entrance
    • Wheelchair accessible parking lot
  • Service options
    • Onsite services
    • Takeout
    • Delivery
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards